Wednesday, February 15, 2012

Homework and the useless father

There comes a time in the life of every parent when they are forced, however grudgingly, to acknowledge a painful reality:

They can no longer help their children with homework.

It hurts to admit this, because what you're essentially saying is, "Yes, this person whose diaper I used to change as recently as 10 minutes ago, it seems, is now learning things that are beyond my capacity to understand. Or if I do have the capacity to learn them, I certainly don't have the time or inclination."

There is no clear-cut dividing line between the time when I was Smart Daddy and when I became Clueless Daddy on the homework front. That's partly because the complexity of your child's schoolwork increases very gradually, and partly because it happens more quickly in some subjects than others.

Take math, for example. My daughter Elissa is studying calculus this year. I never took calculus. I managed to get a college degree from a highly regarded institution of higher learning, yet they never forced me to take calculus. In retrospect, that doesn't seem right.

The end result is that, when Elissa is having trouble with calculus, she knows it's absolutely no use coming to me. Really, if she approached me for help with calculus homework, I would break down crying then and there and ask if there was something easier I could do for her - like building a working model of the solar system out of Corn Flakes.

The same goes with Chloe's geometry homework, and both of the girls' high school-level science homework. Just not my thing. But an English or history essay? Ah, now we're in my territory. No matter how far my kids climb up the academic ladder, I'm confident I will always be able to edit their papers. Writing and editing are what I do every day. That's my sweet spot. Even if I don't fully understand the content, I can make it sound good.

Jared is right about in my transition zone. He's in 7th grade, which is the time when everything starts getting more difficult and out of my Middle-Aged Guy Sphere of Knowledge. Fortunately, Jared is a pretty smart kid and rarely needs help. And when he does, it's in French. I got a pretty solid grounding in French, having taken 14 years of instruction in the language (from 1st grade all the way through my junior year in college). I can still conjugate most of the common verbs, and my vocabulary isn't bad, either. French I can do.

Melanie has been coming home the last couple of years with what would seem to be simple arithmetic problems. Right now they're multiplying three-digit numbers. Easy, right? Well, yeah, I can get the correct answer. It's just that they've changed the method on me.

You remember how we were taught to multiply multi-digit numbers, right? It was a pretty straightforward process of multiplying the top row by each bottom-row digit one at a time, and adding together the resulting products. Short of breaking out a calculator, that's the only way I know how to do it, and it's what the good people who comprised the faculty of Mapledale Elementary School taught me.

But it's not what they teach now, apparently. Now they have the kids breaking out the numbers by the hundreds, tens and ones places in a process that at first seemed to me to be a lot more work until I realized it's actually no harder than the old-fashioned method. AND it would appear to help them understand numerical relationships better. With all my heart I want to scream, "Why can't they just do it the way we used to do it and leave well enough alone?" And all the while I'm thinking to myself, "Hey, this is actually pretty cool."

Jack, meanwhile, is in kindergarten. I can still totally dominate kindergarten. There's nothing school-related Jack asks that I can't answer, which is why he still thinks I know everything. I want this phase to last as long as possible because he's my youngest and therefore the last kid who's going to think that, and I know when the day comes that he starts asking me about quadratic equations, I'll have no choice but to break out the Corn Flakes.

6 comments:

  1. Hi Scott,

    True post - I think any parent can relate. Except teachers, of course.

    I remember the first time I saw lattice, or long division using friendly numbers. Friendly? I don't think so.

    The way I've handled it is to emphasize the awe factor in the traditional methods. I do it really fast and cross things out and just generally make it look as complicated as possible so they are just amazed when I get the same answer. That way we switch the focus from the fact that I have no idea what they're talking about when it comes to what they are learning to the fact that they have no idea what I'm talking about. When they were younger, I simply called it magic. So far I've gotten away with it, although I think Alex is on to me.

    For all other subjects, we google. I explain this is a skill they NEED to learn, of course. And learn it they are. They google EVERYTHING. Songs, lyrics, definitions, science, recipes, history. We may already be at the point where they don't actually need us for much of anything.

    I knew our goal was to create smart, self-sufficient, secure children. I just didn't realize google would make that happen by age 10.

    I'm very intrigued to see your solar system made from corn flakes. Styrofoam balls and coat hangers, yes. Corn flakes, not so much.

    I'm enjoying your blog and I'm glad I came across it. Thanks for your stories.

    ReplyDelete
  2. My secondary school kids (equates to your seniors). In any case we are talking about Chelsea and Dylan can choose to go to an after school class called simply "maths party". All the math teachers are there and they can get one-on-one help if they need it. Chels and Dyl still prefer to go to that than ask Bret (who is a civil engineer and "gets" math). Probably for the reason you suggest - differing methods to get to the same answer....

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great thoughts, Jen. I especially enjoy the "magic" of the old math methods. I wish I would have thought of that years ago. What a wasted opportunity to prolong the illusion of Genius Daddy...And yes, very much agreed on the importance of Google searching. There's actually more of an art to it than people realize. It's knowing WHAT to search for, whether or not to use quotes to search for specific phrases, etc. We're not quite obsolete yet as parents, but in some respects we're getting there! ;)

    ReplyDelete
  4. If Elissa (or the rest, later) need help with Calculus, they can come to me! I love it!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Oh, also, I think that the two methods of multiplication that you described are actually identical- they just look a little different.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I was very pleased to find this web-site. I wanted to thanks for your time for this wonderful read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you blog post.downloaddrasticdsemulatorapk.com

    ReplyDelete